Ernest Wilmowski: A problem of identity

Sep 16, 2020

Life Stories

Ernest Wilmowski

Beginnings

Ernst Otto Prandella (‘Ezi Wilimowski’) was born in Kattowitz, then in the German Empire, in 1916, during the First World War. Both Ernst’s parents were of German descent. His father died fighting for Germany on the Eastern Front. In 1919 Poland became independent, but the region of Upper Silesia was in dispute until a plebiscite in 1921. Kattowitz became the Polish city, Katowice. When his mother remarried, Ernst took his Polish stepfather’s name, Wilmowski.

Poland’s Greatest Goalscorer

Ernest Wilimowski was a right-footed left winger. From the age of 17, he played for Ruch Chorzow.  By 1939, he had scored 112 goals for Ruch, and 21 for his national team. But his international career was interrupted in 1936 when he was suspended for one year because of his heavy drinking. This meant he missed the Olympic Games hosted in Berlin. At the 1938 World Cup, Wilimowski showed his true quality, scoring four goals as Poland lost 6-5 to Brazil. In May 1939 he scored three goals in a 4-2 win over Hungary. But in September 1939 Germany invaded Poland.

Turning Back to Germany

Ernst Wilimowski’s life was utterly changed by the German occupation of Poland. His mother was sent to Auschwitz because her boyfriend was Russian-Jewish. Ernst himself clashed with a local Nazi official. But, as a Volksdeutsche, he was able to claim German citizenship, and so could continue a football career. He played eight wartime international matches for Germany. After 1945, Wilmowski was seen as a traitor in Communist Poland and forbidden to enter the country. He played for several clubs in West Germany until he retired in 1955. Ernest Wilimowski died in Karlsruhe in 1997.

Thinking points

History often forces difficult choices of identity and belonging. Ernest Wilimowski rose to international fame as a great goal scorer for Poland in the 1930s, but he lived the last fifty years of his life in West Germany, forbidden by Poland’s Communist regime ever to return to his homeland. He had been born in Kattowitz, then in the German Empire. His father fought and died for Germany. How come one of “Poland’s greatest” was only “really” Polish from 1922 until 1939.

What does Ernest Wilimowski’s story tell us about the impact of war, nationalism and politics on the life and identities of a famous footballer?

Find out more

The story of Wilmowski’s heroics against Brazil at the 1938 World Cup is told on FIFA. You can also watch some of the footage from the 1938 match between Poland and Brazil on YouTube. Ernest Wilmowski’s turbulent life is detailed further on Wikipedia.

COVER Image

Ernest Wilmowski, match Warta Poznań - Ruch, 15 May 1937 (Source: Światowid / Wikimedia Commons).

Ernest Wilmowski, match Warta Poznań – Ruch, 15 May 1937 (Source: Światowid / Wikimedia Commons).

Life Story

A German-Polish star in the Polish team, and then a player for the Third Reich.

86

Article Tags:   ethnicity  |   identity  |   migration  |   World War 2

Do you wanna know more?

HISTORY CAN BE EXPLORED THROUGH THE LIVES OF INDIVIDUALS

Stories

Browse our collection of stories about football history and inclusion. With the history of football being made up of millions of stories, of individuals and communities, of movements and processes, we offer stories that can inspire our cultural conversations today.

Videos

Get to know untold stories where individuals are making history with football. When faced with insurmountable challenges, individuals past and present can use football as a cultural force to foster positive change in society. We honour these individuals and tell their ‘untold’ stories in short videos.

Educational Resources

Explore our innovative educational resources that use football’s history, heritage and legacy to engage young people. The resources include ready-made lesson plans and historical source collections for school history education as well as toolkit with activities for non-formal settings.

Trending Stories

The Climb to Equality

The Climb to Equality

Football Makes History spoke with Laura Youngson, co-founder of Equal Playing Field and co-owner of the world record for highest altitude official football match ever played. This is the story of why we wanted to retell this story, and how we did it....

LATEST POST  You may also be interested in

Football: A People’s History of Europe?

Football: A People’s History of Europe?

In cooperation with the festival “Forum on European Culture”, we spoke with author David Goldblatt about the value of football for Europe, taking historical perspectives.

Playing the game for peace

Playing the game for peace

On this day, 21 September, we look at how playing a game of football can contribute to peace by looking at the work of the NGO Childrens Football Alliance.

September in Football

September in Football

As the UEFA 2020 European Championships got pushed ahead one year, we provide you with a 365-day #onthisday series of posts to help all fans out there to go back in time, think, and reflect.

Football speaking out in perspective

Football speaking out in perspective

Football represents a large cultural space in society. It is not isolated from political developments. How have football players used this space to achieve their social goals?

Share This